Summary: This was a surprisingly great read thanks to a lot of positives. The player detail section was extremely solid and the NFL info section was top notch. There could've been a few more articles on drafting and strategy, but Fantasy Guide is good for a wide range of fantasy owners.
Positives: The Fantasy Guide has a really nice player detail section and some solid statistics throughout its magazine. It also has an outstanding NFL info section.
Negatives: It lacks expert consensus rankings and could use a few more cheat sheets. It could also have a few more unique articles.
Overall Score: 74
| Date Reviewed: | 7/20/2007 |
| Total Number of Pages: | 152 |
| Number of Pages of Ads: | 4 |
| Number of Pages of Content: | 148 |
| Cost: | $6.99 |
| Content Pages per Dollar: | 21 |
| Free Web Updates?: | None |
| Analysis & Rankings By: | Various writers |
| Draft Day Worksheet(s)?: | Yes |
| Player Pictures?: | Some |
| Player(s) on Cover: | Tom Brady |
| Pictures of Women?: | Few to None |
| Paper Type: | Black/White & Color |
| Number of Years of Fantasy Mags: | Unavailable |
| Affiliations: | RFP LLC |
| Sign up now to see Fantasy Football Analysis data from every magazine we have reviewed. |
| What Is Included: | |
| This is premium content. This section of our review provides objective assessments of 26 criteria. Sign up now to get this content. | |
| What Is Missing: | |
| This is premium content. This section of our review provides objective assessments of 26 criteria. Sign up now to get this content. |
| Sign up now to see Player Detail data from every magazine we have reviewed. |
| General Info: | |
| This is premium content. Sign up now to get this content. | |
| What Is Included: | |
| This is premium content. This section of our review provides objective assessments of 17 criteria. Sign up now to get this content. | |
| What Is Missing: | |
| This is premium content. This section of our review provides objective assessments of 17 criteria. Sign up now to get this content. |
| Player Rankings Accuracy: | |
| This is premium content. Sign up now to get this content. | |
| Summary Information: | |
| Scoring System: | Unclear |
| Ranking Tiers?: | Yes |
| Number of QB/RB/WR/TE Listed: | 240 |
| Number of QB's Ranked & Analyzed: | 32 |
| Number of Other QB's Mentioned: | 19 |
| Number of RB's Ranked & Analyzed: | 68 |
| Number of Other RB's Mentioned: | 0 |
| Number of WR's Ranked & Analyzed: | 79 |
| Number of Other WR's Mentioned: | 11 |
| Number of TE's Ranked & Analyzed: | 31 |
| Number of Other TE's Mentioned: | 0 |
| Comparison to Other Magazines: | |
| Mike Vick's Rank: | About average |
| Jay Cutler's Rank: | Slightly worse than average |
| JaMarcus Russell's Rank: | Much better than average |
| Shaun Alexander's Rank | Much better than average |
| Adrian Peterson's (MIN) Rank: | Much worse than average |
| Brandon Jacobs's Rank: | Slightly worse than average |
| Randy Moss's Rank: | Much better than average |
| Calvin Johnson's Rank: | About average |
| Reggie Williams's Rank: | Slightly better than average |
| Kellen Winslow's Rank: | Much better than average |
| Greg Olsen's Rank: | Slightly worse than average |
| Adam Vinatieri's Rank: | Much worse than average |
| Neil Rackers' Rank: | Slightly better than average |
| Jaguars' Rank: | Much better than average |
| Raiders' Rank: | Much better than average |
| What Is Included: | |
| Game by Game Breakdown | |
| What Is Missing: | |
| Pages of Stats | |
| Passing | |
| Rushing | |
| Receiving | |
| Field Goals | |
| Scoring | |
| Scoring (non-kickers) | |
| Punt Returns | |
| Kickoff Returns | |
| Tackles | |
| Sacks | |
| Fumble Recoveries | |
| Interceptions | |
| QB Stats | |
| RB Stats | |
| WR Stats | |
| TE Stats | |
| K Stats | |
| Defensive Positions | |
| Team Defense | |
| Team Offense | |
| Fantasy Points | |
| Fantasy Points Per Game | |
| Pass Targets | |
| Redzone Production | |
| Yardage Frequency | |
| Games Played Included | |
| Games Started Included | |
| What Is Included: | |
| 2 | Page(s) Per Team |
| NFL Schedule by Team | |
| Team Summaries | |
| Team Depth Charts | |
| Rookie Analysis | |
| Coaching Changes Analysis | |
| Top Player Stats | |
| Keyshawn Johnson's Retirement | |
| Trent Green's Trade | |
| What Is Missing: | |
| NFL Schedule by Week | |
| Offseason Moves Summary | |
| Bye Week Chart | |
| Strength of Schedule Info | |
| Offseason Grades | |
| Team Predictions | |
| Fantasy Strategy Articles | |
| 4 | Strategic Articles |
| 17 | Pages of Strategic Articles |
| Scouting Articles: |
Young Bloods - Lookie Here, Lookie Here Writer's Wroundelay Retread or Shred |
| Drafting Articles: | |
| In-Season Articles: | We Poll the Writers |
| Non-Strategic Fantasy Articles | |
| 1 | Non-Strategic Articles |
| 1 | Pages of Non-Strategic Articles |
| League Releated Articles: | |
| Interview Articles: | |
| Humor Articles: | A Gambling Life |
 |
 |